Average elixir cost is not cycle speed: what the 4-card cycle number tells you

Published

Every deck screen shows one number above all others: the average elixir cost. It is useful, but it answers a different question from the one most players think it answers. The average tells you roughly how expensive the deck is to play. It does not tell you how quickly you can get back to the card that actually wins you the game. For that you need a second number, the 4-card cycle cost, and you can work it out by hand in a few seconds.

How the card cycle works

A deck has eight cards. At any moment four of them are in your hand and the other four wait in a queue, with the next one shown in the small slot beside your hand. When you play a card, it goes to the back of the queue, and the card at the front of the queue comes into your hand.

That has one simple consequence: after you play a card, you must play four other cards before you can play it again. It sits at the back of a queue of four, and each card you play moves it forward by one place.

So the real question for a deck that relies on one win condition, such as Hog Rider, Miner or Graveyard, is: once I have played my win condition, how much elixir does it cost me to get it back? The answer is the cost of the four other cards you play in between. If you play your four cheapest cards, that is the cheapest possible cycle back. That sum is the 4-card cycle cost.

Working it out by hand

  1. Take your deck and set the win condition aside.
  2. From the remaining seven cards, pick the four cheapest.
  3. Add their costs. That is your 4-card cycle cost.

If the deck has two win conditions, do it for each. If you care about a key defensive card (say, an Inferno Tower against a beatdown opponent), the same method tells you how quickly that card comes back.

Two decks with the same average

Here are two decks with the same average elixir cost of 2.6. Costs are those in the game at the time of writing.

Deck A, a classic Hog Rider cycle deck:

Card Cost
Hog Rider 4
Musketeer 4
Fireball 4
Cannon 3
Ice Golem 2
The Log 2
Ice Spirit 1
Skeletons 1

Total 21, average 2.6. Set Hog Rider aside, and the four cheapest cards are Ice Spirit, Skeletons, Ice Golem and The Log: 1 + 1 + 2 + 2 = 6 elixir to get Hog Rider back.

Deck B, a Miner deck built only from 2- and 3-cost cards:

Card Cost
Miner 3
Knight 3
Archers 3
Goblin Gang 3
Bandit 3
Bats 2
Zap 2
The Log 2

Also total 21, average 2.6. Set Miner aside, and the four cheapest cards are Bats, Zap, The Log and one 3-cost card: 2 + 2 + 2 + 3 = 9 elixir to get Miner back.

Same average, and yet Deck A gets back to its win condition for two thirds of the elixir Deck B needs. At the normal single-elixir rate you gain one elixir roughly every 2.8 seconds, so those three extra elixir are about eight and a half seconds of generation. That is the gap between your opponent having their counter in hand or not.

The difference comes from the shape of the deck, not its average. Deck A pays for two 4-cost cards and a 4-cost spell with two 1-cost cards. Deck B has no expensive cards, but also no cheap ones.

What the number is good for

Comparing decks for the same job. If you are choosing between two versions of a cycle deck, the one with the lower 4-card cycle gets more attacks per minute with its win condition. In a deck built to chip the tower again and again, that is the whole point.

Knowing when you can out-cycle a counter. Suppose your opponent’s only clean answer to your Hog Rider is a building, such as a Tesla. If you know they just played it, and you know your own cycle back costs 6, you can work out whether your Hog Rider will be back before their counter is. The guide on tracking your opponent’s cycle shows the matching count on their side.

Spotting a deck that cannot pressure. A 4-card cycle of 10 or more means that, between two plays of the win condition, you spend at least ten elixir on other cards. That is fine for a beatdown deck that builds one huge push, but it is a problem for a deck that wants to punish every mistake quickly.

What it does not tell you

It is a best case. You only get the cheapest cycle if your cheap cards are in hand when you need them. Often they are not: they are sitting in the queue because you just used them. In practice your cycle back is usually somewhat more expensive than the number on paper. Treat the number as a lower bound.

Cheap cards still have to do something. Cycling an Ice Spirit or Skeletons into an empty lane gains you nothing but position in the cycle. The best cycle plays are the ones that also defend: Skeletons to distract a Prince, Ice Spirit to reset an Inferno Tower. A deck with a low cycle cost but cheap cards that never trade well loses elixir every time it cycles.

Champions change the count. While a Champion is on the arena, it is not in your cycle at all, so the deck cycles through seven cards instead of eight, and a card you play comes back after only three others. That is explained in How Champions change the card cycle.

Double elixir shrinks the gap in seconds. When elixir comes in twice as fast, a 3-elixir difference in cycle cost is only about four seconds. Cycle decks still play the same way, but the heavier deck catches up. See Single-elixir vs double-elixir.

Using it when you build a deck

When you put a deck together, write down two numbers rather than one: the average cost and the 4-card cycle back to each win condition. A few rules of thumb:

If the numbers do not suit the deck’s plan, swap one card. Replacing a 3-cost card with a 1-cost card of similar job (Skeletons for a Knight is the classic, if rough, swap) lowers the average by 0.25 and the cycle cost by 2. The five-minute deck checklist puts this check alongside the others a deck needs, and the deck builder works out both numbers for every card as you put a deck together.