Spell value explained: when to spend a spell on troops vs the tower
Published
A spell is the only card that can hit a tower without crossing the bridge. That makes it tempting to throw spells at the tower whenever the opponent has nothing on the arena. Sometimes that is right. Often it trades a card you will need in ten seconds for damage that does not matter. This guide gives a way to decide.
Two kinds of value
Every spell has two possible jobs:
- Troop value: removing or weakening troops worth more elixir than the spell costs, or that would otherwise do serious damage.
- Tower value: damage to a crown tower that brings it closer to falling.
Spells deal reduced damage to crown towers: each spell’s card stats show its tower damage separately, and it is a fraction of the damage it deals to troops. That reduction is why most spells are worth more on troops in the first two minutes.
The break-even rule for troops
A spell on troops pays off when it removes, or neutralises, more elixir than it costs. Neutralising counts: a Fireball that leaves a Musketeer almost dead, so your tower kills it in one shot, has done the job.
Examples with costs at the time of writing:
- Fireball (4) on Musketeer (4) is even on its own. If it also hits the tower, or a second troop, it is positive.
- Fireball (4) on Barbarians (5) is positive if it leaves them weak enough for your tower and a cheap troop to finish.
- The Log (2) on Goblin Gang (3) or Zap (2) on Skeleton Army (3) is +1 and stops a swarm that would otherwise do a lot of damage.
- Poison (4) on a group of Minions (3) and Goblins (2) is +1, more with tower damage.
- Rocket (6) on an Elixir Collector (6) is even, but often still worth it, because the collector would have paid for itself.
A spell on troops that would die to the tower anyway, or that is replaced immediately by something more dangerous, has less value than the numbers say. Ask whether the troops would have mattered.
The break-even rule for the tower
A spell on the tower alone is a trade of elixir for damage. It pays off when that damage wins something the elixir could not:
- It finishes a tower. If the tower’s health is below the spell’s tower damage, cast it. One crown is worth more than any amount of elixir.
- It sets up a finish. If the spell brings the tower into range of a second spell or a win condition hit you can surely land, it is worth it.
- There is nothing better to do with the elixir. In the last seconds of a match, unused elixir is worth nothing.
Outside those cases, a spell on the tower usually costs you the card when you need it. If the opponent answers by playing a swarm you can no longer clear, the “free” damage was not free.
The last minute changes the maths
Two things shift as the match ends:
Elixir is cheaper. In double elixir you gain one elixir about every 1.4 seconds. A four-elixir Fireball is under six seconds of generation, and you will have it back in your hand soon. See Single-elixir vs double-elixir.
Time is shorter. With twenty seconds left, the question is no longer “what is this worth over the match” but “can this end the match, or stop it from ending against me”. A spell that might be needed on defence in thirty seconds is not needed if there are no thirty seconds left.
A practical rule for the end of regulation and for overtime:
- Last thirty seconds: if a spell on the tower brings it close enough to fall to your next push, cast it.
- Last ten seconds: if a spell can finish the tower, cast it. If not, cast it anyway if your elixir would otherwise be wasted and you are not defending.
- Overtime (sudden death): keep one spell back to defend your weakest tower until you can finish theirs. The opponent is counting the same numbers.
Spells on troops and tower together
The best spells hit both. Placing a Fireball or Poison so that it catches a troop and the tower gives you troop value and tower damage in one card. Three habits make this happen more often:
- When defending near your bridge, look for troops standing near their own tower, such as a Musketeer or a Wizard placed behind it. Spells cast there usually catch the tower.
- When your win condition reaches the tower, the opponent will defend in front of it. A spell on their defenders then also hits the tower.
- Do not move the spell away from the tower to catch one extra troop of little value. The tower damage adds up over a match.
The worked example in Elixir trades in practice includes a Fireball that removes a Musketeer and chips the tower that later falls.
Small spells
Small spells (The Log, Zap, Snowball, Arrows, Barbarian Barrel) are usually worth more on troops, because the swarms they counter would otherwise cost you much more than two or three elixir. Most decks have only one small spell, and the opponent will try to bait it out before playing the swarm it answers. Using it on the tower is rarely right until the last few seconds, or to finish a tower with very little health.
Checking your deck
If your deck has no bigger spell, you cannot finish towers this way, and you lose many close games. If it has only a big spell and no small one, swarms will cost you much more than they should. The five-minute deck checklist checks for both.